Sunday, January 27, 2008

*1 The Utiliarianism of John Stuart Mill

Preface: Utilitarianism is a form of consequentialism conceived by philosopher Jeremy Bentham. Simply, it is a system of ethics that commands the greatest good for the greatest amount of people be fulfilled. “Greatest good” refers usually to “happiness” in quantitative terms (the source of much criticism).

***John Stuart Mill***

The son of a Scottish historian and philosopher James Mill, and the godson of Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill was seemingly predestined to invest his intellectual abilities in the utilitarianism of his literal forefathers.

The divergence between John and his predecessors concerns the actual nature of "happiness." Jeremy Bentham reduced the greatest happiness no further than general happiness. John Stuart Mill, however, created a quasi-hierarchy of happiness. Glee that is the product of passion or physical fulfillment, he contends in his famous Utilitarianism (1863), is of a lower rank than intellectual and moral satisfaction. This sentiment is echoed bythe famous line from Utilitarianism: "It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied. And if the fool, or the pig, are a different opinion, it is because they only know their own side of the question."

Mill proposed that the foundation of happiness lies in the fact that fulfillment through "higher forms" such as art and formal music provides a higher quality of happiness than the simple pleasures in life, such as a ray of sunlight on the skin. Mill was a proponent of offering more voting rights to college graduates, who would know the "finer" things in life, and vote to invest in "higher quality" happiness outlets such as the opera, rather than a bar, perhaps.

***

The values of Mill, as exhibited in his work, leave me with a primary concern. Does his form of utilitarianism lead to elitism and eventual aristocratic suppression of lower classes that don't understand the finer things in life?

I also question the basis he lays for his happiness hierarchy. Can happiness be expressed in quantitative terms without measuring electric pulses within the brain of every individual within a society? Where is the practicality to this method of allocating resources?


1 comment:

Mr. McMaken said...

John Stuart Mill...Though he is primarily associated heavily with this whole "greatest good for greatest number of people" thing (utilitarianism), he is certainly one of the most interesting "liberal" thinkers and was ahead of his time in gender relations.

Your post is excellent. At the end, you raise questions about the consequences of this "line of thinking" -- that "true" happiness must come from philosophy and high arts not "sunlight" on the skin. If anyone read my first post ('Window of Opportunity'), it is obvious that I believe that "true happiness" CAN and should come from such "God-given" things as sunlight .

I very much agree that this smacks of elitism, but no more than many of the 19th century thinkers that we will be studying this week.

In fact, John Stuart Mill is on the Study Guide I will be handing out tomorrow.

Great post, Brian.