Saturday, February 16, 2008

Victor Hugo, the Subjectivist

"Popularity? It is glory's small change."
-Victor Hugo

Victor-Marie Hugo was born February 6, 1802 to a high-ranking officer in Napoleon's army, Joseph Léopold Sigisbert Hugo, and an ardent Catholic Royalist, Sophie Trébuchet. The dynamics of the political affiliations of Hugo's family was a direct reflection of his time. A few years prior to his birth, the dethroning of the Bourbons from the French government occurred, replaced by the New Republic, only to be replaced during the restoration of the French monarchy in 1814.

Though Hugo was moreover under the influence of his conservative mother as a child, his political mindset slowly began to take on the ideas of the left. During the events leading to the Revolution of 1848, he began to champion Republican ideas in lieu of his mother’s Royalist rearing.

Like many other Romantic writers, Hugo was heavily influenced by François-René de Chateaubriand. Under the influence of “Chateaubriand or nothing,” as Hugo said, he began to bear the cause of Romanticism and became heavily involved in politics, furthering the cause of Republicanism. This relentless support of Republicanism reflected the ideas of Romanticism; inherent in Republicanism is a foundation of individuality. His never-produced theatrical piece, Cromwell, is considered a bridge between French Classicism and Romanticism. In the preface of the work, he urged his contemporaries to exalt themselves in Romantic ideas, and to free themselves from classical art.

Hugo, though a lyrical and poetical mastermind, is most remembered for his full-length novels. One of his most successful is
Notre-Dame de Paris. Individualism springs from the pages of the book, as exhibited here:

Each had made his choice; one, the bonfire; another, the
maypole; another, the mystery play. It must be stated, in
honor of the good sense of the loungers of Paris, that the
greater part of this crowd directed their steps towards the
bonfire, which was quite in season, or towards the mystery
play, which was to be presented in the grand hall of the
Palais de Justice (the courts of law), which was well roofed
and walled; and that the curious left the poor, scantily flowered
maypole to shiver all alone beneath the sky of January,
in the cemetery of the Chapel of Braque.
The book concerns itself primarily with the social strifes that were at the root of the French Revolution pre-1789, but this passage demonstrates that individualism and individual choice were also key themes of the novel. "Each had made their choice," and although they were insignificant choices, they were still decisions made by individuals. This excerpt, so concerned with the components of a composited crowd, is deep-seated with Republican ideals of choice.

It is a little-known fact that Hugo was not only a gifted writer, but an equally prolific visual artist. Delacroix wrote to Hugo once saying that had he become an artist rather than a writer, he would have outshone the artists of his time.

In this surprisingly modern piece,
Taches with Fingerprints, the most evident Romantic motif is the subjective experience. The viewer is placed, disturbingly, at the vantage point of the subject. We appear to be at the bottom of some pit, being looked at by passerby. Whether or not we, at the bottom of the pit, are victims of the observers is arguable, but we are obviously below them. It appears that this work is making a statement about social injustice, as much of Hugo's work does.




Hugo's work continued far past the Romantic "era" in the nineteenth-century; his influence if felt heavily in the work of figures such as Albert Camus and Fyodor Dostoevsky. Miranda July, a modern avante-garde (though I hate that title for its pretentiousness, but it will have to suffice) performance artist/author/film director/actress, is one social commentator who is brimming with Hugo-ness. Her work concentrates on the idiosyncrasies, particularly sometimes disturbing neurotic behaviors, that are the result of living in an increasingly alienating and emotionally agonizing world. Her characters are all very contemplative, and her style is very stream-of-conscience: reflecting the Romantic obsession with the subjective experience, as Hugo was concerned with writing about.

Sources:
1
2
3
4

Friday, February 8, 2008

*3 To what extent does Romanticism influence modern music?

Thesis: Romanticism influenced movements that would follow it in all categories: intellectual, social, music, art, literature, etc. Music, particularly, still pays heavy homage to the Romantics. Modern music is lyrically passionate, devoted to the emotions, and dramatic in orchestration.

Romanticism was a nineteenth-century artistic, literary, and intellectual movement that originated in the latter half of the eighteenth-century in Western Europe. A reaction against the societal status quo that had arisen out of the Enlightenment and the harshness of the Scientific Revolution, Romanticism was a movement that emphasized the human emotions associated with experiences as the pinnacle of aesthetics.

My emphasis, Romantic music, relegates itself to approximately the time period of 1810 to 1910. This includes artists from Beethoven to later on Wagner. Three common attributes found in the various genres of nineteenth-century Romantic music are: rejection of classical formal structure, a regressive attitude that embraces folk music and myth, and dramatic orchestration.

Like the Enlightenment, the Romantic movement continues to penetrate our art and our lives. Its ideas are so prevalent that most of this time period's values are inescapable in how modern music, lyrically and compositionally.

Here are examples of modern music that convey direct Romantic influence:


In “Venus in Furs” by the transformative Velvet Underground & Nico, the music itself is the most obvious rebellion against convention; but the lyrics are rebellious as well, discussing what was in the sixties, and still today, the taboo subject of the underground S&M world.


In “Postcards from Italy,” by the group Beirut, all of the instruments used are Eastern European traditional or derivatives thereof. After spending teenage years in the Balkans amongst gypsies, Zach Condon of Beirut began writing music that was directly influenced by them. This directly reflects the “back to” mentality that glorified folk music during the Romantic period.


Even music as obscure and non-conventional as ’00 “shoegazing” falls within the parameters of Romanticism that our art seems so tied to. The climatic nature of “23” by Blonde-Redhead is an excellent composition that exhibits dramatic orchestration. There are definite highs and lows that provide the musical contrast and drama that the Romantic composers were so famous for.

Sources:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanticism#Romanticism_and_music
http://www.tiscali.co.uk/reference/encyclopaedia/hutchinson/m0019061.html
http://www.rpfuller.com/gcse/music/romantic.html

Monday, February 4, 2008

DBQ Exercise: Thesis and First Body Paragraph

The Industrial Revolution, particularly during the nineteenth-century, proved truly transformative for European cities. Manchester, England was transformed into a virtual living factory, with the pulse of human innovation and likewise the exhalation of human degradation. Among the people, reactions to the newly industrialized cities were often as polarized as the figures of their income and living conditions.

The fruit of the Industrial Revolution was supposed increased productivity, and the tragic dross was the alleged disparaging of the urban working people. The landscape of the city had indubitably changed to one of toxic waste and cramped quarters. English Romantic poet Robert Southey wrote that the smog that floated constantly above the city had transformed the façade of the buildings, and refers to the people within them as “wretches.” (doc.2) People were indeed becoming more productive, but that is because machinery is productive; and from an emotional perspective, as Southey demonstrates, the people were reduced to mechanistic parts of a giant industrial machine. As important as manual labor was, the increased productivity was a result of innovation from the top, from the thinkers. The idea that the industrial movement in cities like Manchester was a pyramid of innovation and labor was expressed by Frances Anne Kemble, whose observation of an inaugural journey split people into either protestor or “nobility.” She groups all of the plebeians into a group that possesses a “dangerous discontent with the Government.” (doc. 5). This discontent fired the socialist reaction against the classical liberalism model of the classes. Progress was a common goal among the rich and poor, but progress, Flora Tristan, a French socialist, asserted in her journal that progress cannot be bought at the “cost of men’s lives.” (doc.7). This socialist attitude disdained the classical liberal ideas of no government intervention to help people, and regarded the once liberal idea of laissez-faire as cruelly conservative.

Sunday, February 3, 2008

*2 What was the role of psychology during the Industrial Revolution?

The Industrial Revolution was not an overnight phenomena, and occurred in stages that led to greater efficiency--the greatest, perhaps, led to the happiness of the worker through a novel form of applied "industrial" psychology.

The first major character in the story of industrial psychology is Frederick Winslow Taylor, or the "father of scientific management." Although the idea of efficiency through "scientific management" (standardization of work to ensure efficient production) had been commented on for centuries, even by figures such as Ben Franklin in the quote aphorism "Buy what thou hast no need of, and ere long thou shalt sell thy necessaries," Taylor was the perfecter. This new methodology of management brought to light many problems within the workplace that were hindering to efficiency, primarily through criticism Taylor received. Because scientific management sought a universal "correct" way to perform a task, Taylor's methods met criticism for its indifference to the individual nuances of the worker. One way of picking up a brick might be efficient in theory, but may not be practical for a worker, say, who has back problems. These concerns were addressed with industrial psychology.

Hugo Münsterberg
was one of the pioneers of the industrial psychology movement. Although a critic of Taylor, he was also an admirer for what he had began. He wrote: "Our aim is to sketch the outlines of a new science, which is to intermediate between the modern laboratory psychology and the problems of economics." Münsterberg wanted to gain access to the most "correct" efficiency, but realized first that complete uniformity in choreography was impossible, and people must be fitted to their jobs. The fact that he acknowledged people must actually enjoy their job somewhat was radical. "Happy worker, happy plant, high quality product" was fundamentally new.

His Psychology and Industrial Efficiency(1913) was primarily concerned with the contentedness of the worker. It explains that fatigue, monotony, and repetition can dull the worker; this disillusionment with uniform productivity, he argues, produces a lower-quality product, or less of due to slowed efficiency in the long-run. With this idea, Münsterberg illustrates that the now antediluvian efficiency of scientific management is good only in the short-term, and its psychological effects are damaging in the long-run, which is valued more.

The incorporation of workers' psychology into the production formula laid the groundwork for the soon-to-come progressive era.

Sources:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Winslow_Taylor#Relations_with_ASME
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_management#Criticism
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_M%C3%BCnsterberg#Works
http://www.makingthemodernworld.org.uk/stories/the_age_of_the_mass/05.ST.06/?scene=3