Monday, February 4, 2008

DBQ Exercise: Thesis and First Body Paragraph

The Industrial Revolution, particularly during the nineteenth-century, proved truly transformative for European cities. Manchester, England was transformed into a virtual living factory, with the pulse of human innovation and likewise the exhalation of human degradation. Among the people, reactions to the newly industrialized cities were often as polarized as the figures of their income and living conditions.

The fruit of the Industrial Revolution was supposed increased productivity, and the tragic dross was the alleged disparaging of the urban working people. The landscape of the city had indubitably changed to one of toxic waste and cramped quarters. English Romantic poet Robert Southey wrote that the smog that floated constantly above the city had transformed the façade of the buildings, and refers to the people within them as “wretches.” (doc.2) People were indeed becoming more productive, but that is because machinery is productive; and from an emotional perspective, as Southey demonstrates, the people were reduced to mechanistic parts of a giant industrial machine. As important as manual labor was, the increased productivity was a result of innovation from the top, from the thinkers. The idea that the industrial movement in cities like Manchester was a pyramid of innovation and labor was expressed by Frances Anne Kemble, whose observation of an inaugural journey split people into either protestor or “nobility.” She groups all of the plebeians into a group that possesses a “dangerous discontent with the Government.” (doc. 5). This discontent fired the socialist reaction against the classical liberalism model of the classes. Progress was a common goal among the rich and poor, but progress, Flora Tristan, a French socialist, asserted in her journal that progress cannot be bought at the “cost of men’s lives.” (doc.7). This socialist attitude disdained the classical liberal ideas of no government intervention to help people, and regarded the once liberal idea of laissez-faire as cruelly conservative.

4 comments:

Pooh Bear said...

Surprise..I just wanted to stop by and make a comment on your DBQ exercise. I have to say that you are an amazing writer and i have to admit that most of it i was lost, not because it didn't make sense but because ofmy part. I lack a big vocabulary. Anyways, i thought that your two paragraphs were logically and every tme you mentioned a new document,it flowed easily togehter. No critism here..

Pooh Bear said...

i meant to say..logical..

Julianne said...

Let me say sir that your first two paragraphs are amazing. The only thing I could think of is that you might want to make your points of view a wee bit more prominent. Other than that it's perfecto.

Marie said...

Yeah, I totally didnt notice you points of view. I believe I saw one but I couldnt find the second...otherwise love the verbiage homeslice! ;P It's way better than mine is for sure. Brilliant use of the Documents.