Sunday, March 2, 2008

Question #3: Is the US truly nationalistic these days?

A fan of contemporary “country” music, I am not, but I think that a feud between two country music superstars, Toby Keith and Natalie Maines of the Dixie Chicks, within the past few years illustrates the point I will attempt to make in this entry.

Toby Keith, in his blue-collar yippin’ and hollerin’ tribute to Uncle Sam, offers a simply damaging portrayal of Americans and the “American way.” Likening the “American way” to “a boot in your a**,” he tends to leave out, oh, I don’t know, diplomacy in the world abroad. I believe Natalie Maines put it more eloquently, though, with the word “ignorant.” In a time of hot-headed blind patriotism, this song, although written in response to 9/11 and pre-Second Gulf War, to most war-mongering patriots of the American cause view it as an anthem to stick a boot up the you-know-what of some “ragheads,” as Anne Coulter would say.

I believe that the previous paragraph shows how I exuberantly disagree with the politics of Toby Keith and the like.

And herein lies the divisiveness that is causing contemporary America to question its sense of self, sense of direction, and what it was pre-9/11: our mission.

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy defines nationalism as (1) the attitude that the members of a nation have when they care about their national identity and (2) the actions that the members of a nation take when seeking to achieve (or sustain) self-determination. The key term in these definitions is “members.” Members are the individuals involved in creating or sustaining a national identity.

Is the U.S. truly nationalistic these days? To ask whether or not a piece of paper flat is a more objective question, but to ask whether or not any land mass is nationalistic is complicatedly arbitrary. The degree of nationalism exhibited in our country is dependent upon individual and group perspective. The opinion of many that follow blind patriotism resembles that of Toby Keith: we are a nation that should rule the world and drive our trucks because it’s the American way. My view of American nationalism is one of nostalgia. As Melissa said, “…the sense of patriotism that surged after this tragedy [Sept 11] was more to reassure ourselves.” We were reassuring ourselves of what we were. My sense of nationalism has faded into a memory and I’m moreover disaffected with my connecting with one nation and a unified cause. I know there are other views, but for my purposes I’m only going to discuss these two.

The nationalism of nineteenth-century Europe and modern nationalism, particularly the American brand, are different. Our nationalism is predominantly either a sense of protection or longing for a sense previously felt, while the nationalism of the Grecian and German people, for instance, were ones of formation. Creation and preservation resonate in distinctly different tones. Creation is a process that entails unity and a dialectic of what actually “is” between people and groups in an ultimate creation—in this instance a nation. Creation can also be multi-national, as seen when in Delacroix’s Massacre at Chios. This back-and-forth creation is contradictory, and vital to the development of an idea. Preservation, our current agenda, of what is (or was) creates a different type divisiveness because it is a process that involves recognition of what we have, and where we have come from since our creation, both extremely subjective and intangible ideas. Creation can be anything, because it an awaiting for the future to be molded from the present, while preservation can only be one thing at the present.

This leads me to my final argument in this extremely brief writing on a consuming idea. The age of preservation and the nation-state seems somewhat antediluvian. Creation, a unifying cause, needs to occur worldwide. With the precedent of the multicultural European Union, do we not see the inherent value in opening a line of communication amongst people worldwide? Performing odd rituals with boots for the sake of extremist democracy is no more effective than flying planes into buildings in the name of martyrdom and extreme religious views.

Provided that communication and cooperation play large roles in the new frontier of world-wide creation, terror and attacks upon liberty may become less prevalent. During this process, maybe more maps will become available too so that we don’t become involved in factitious wars.

No comments: