Saturday, February 16, 2008

Victor Hugo, the Subjectivist

"Popularity? It is glory's small change."
-Victor Hugo

Victor-Marie Hugo was born February 6, 1802 to a high-ranking officer in Napoleon's army, Joseph Léopold Sigisbert Hugo, and an ardent Catholic Royalist, Sophie Trébuchet. The dynamics of the political affiliations of Hugo's family was a direct reflection of his time. A few years prior to his birth, the dethroning of the Bourbons from the French government occurred, replaced by the New Republic, only to be replaced during the restoration of the French monarchy in 1814.

Though Hugo was moreover under the influence of his conservative mother as a child, his political mindset slowly began to take on the ideas of the left. During the events leading to the Revolution of 1848, he began to champion Republican ideas in lieu of his mother’s Royalist rearing.

Like many other Romantic writers, Hugo was heavily influenced by François-René de Chateaubriand. Under the influence of “Chateaubriand or nothing,” as Hugo said, he began to bear the cause of Romanticism and became heavily involved in politics, furthering the cause of Republicanism. This relentless support of Republicanism reflected the ideas of Romanticism; inherent in Republicanism is a foundation of individuality. His never-produced theatrical piece, Cromwell, is considered a bridge between French Classicism and Romanticism. In the preface of the work, he urged his contemporaries to exalt themselves in Romantic ideas, and to free themselves from classical art.

Hugo, though a lyrical and poetical mastermind, is most remembered for his full-length novels. One of his most successful is
Notre-Dame de Paris. Individualism springs from the pages of the book, as exhibited here:

Each had made his choice; one, the bonfire; another, the
maypole; another, the mystery play. It must be stated, in
honor of the good sense of the loungers of Paris, that the
greater part of this crowd directed their steps towards the
bonfire, which was quite in season, or towards the mystery
play, which was to be presented in the grand hall of the
Palais de Justice (the courts of law), which was well roofed
and walled; and that the curious left the poor, scantily flowered
maypole to shiver all alone beneath the sky of January,
in the cemetery of the Chapel of Braque.
The book concerns itself primarily with the social strifes that were at the root of the French Revolution pre-1789, but this passage demonstrates that individualism and individual choice were also key themes of the novel. "Each had made their choice," and although they were insignificant choices, they were still decisions made by individuals. This excerpt, so concerned with the components of a composited crowd, is deep-seated with Republican ideals of choice.

It is a little-known fact that Hugo was not only a gifted writer, but an equally prolific visual artist. Delacroix wrote to Hugo once saying that had he become an artist rather than a writer, he would have outshone the artists of his time.

In this surprisingly modern piece,
Taches with Fingerprints, the most evident Romantic motif is the subjective experience. The viewer is placed, disturbingly, at the vantage point of the subject. We appear to be at the bottom of some pit, being looked at by passerby. Whether or not we, at the bottom of the pit, are victims of the observers is arguable, but we are obviously below them. It appears that this work is making a statement about social injustice, as much of Hugo's work does.




Hugo's work continued far past the Romantic "era" in the nineteenth-century; his influence if felt heavily in the work of figures such as Albert Camus and Fyodor Dostoevsky. Miranda July, a modern avante-garde (though I hate that title for its pretentiousness, but it will have to suffice) performance artist/author/film director/actress, is one social commentator who is brimming with Hugo-ness. Her work concentrates on the idiosyncrasies, particularly sometimes disturbing neurotic behaviors, that are the result of living in an increasingly alienating and emotionally agonizing world. Her characters are all very contemplative, and her style is very stream-of-conscience: reflecting the Romantic obsession with the subjective experience, as Hugo was concerned with writing about.

Sources:
1
2
3
4

10 comments:

Megahertz said...

I love the quote at the beginning of your post, it was a good way to start it off, and is a pretty interesting quote.
I had never even heard of François-René de Chateaubriand before your post, however after looking him up it does seem that he has influenced many people of the Romantic times. Do you know any of the other people that were influenced by him off the top of your head?
Was Hugo's theatrical piece, Cromwell, in any way related to Oliver Cromwell?
I absolutely love the Taches with Fingerprints work. But for some reason before I read your analysis I hadn't thought of it like that. I see how it looks that way now, of course, but to me it resembled the front of a women's chest, and the fingerprints almost like parts of a necklace, and the white part the chest/neck area, and the rest parts of a dress.
Miranda July looks like a swell person, your post made me want to check out her works.
Yay :D

Steph it up =] said...

Well my first question would have to be, Why is his middle name Marie? but onto a more serious note, I loved this post. The information you presented was great and really helped me understand him as a person and writer. Besides the Revolutions of 1848, what caused Hugo to lean towards the left and away from his mothers beliefs? and its probably only me who will ask this but who exactly is François-René de Chateaubriand?
The piece he did, "Taches with Fingerprints" was pretty weird. however, to me they do not look like fingerprints. I couldn't tell you what it looks like because i don't know. Although, I think its very original.
Along with Chateaubriand, i don't know who Miranda July is, but your descriptions about her actions have really made me want to look into her works.

Marie said...

Clearly Marie is a winning name! =P Anyway I really liked this post because I didn’t know anything about Victor Hugo although I have heard of him before. The first thing I noticed was that he grew up in a conservative house hold but grew up to be a very liberal thinking man. As I am pretty much living that same life I wonder if it’s common for children who grow up in conservative house holds to be liberal. It also made me wonder if there could be a conservative romantic writer/artist. I like how he emphasized individuality because I also believe that is important , but it makes me wonder if people realize that in the world today be all have our own individual say because people see more apt to just follow the trend then consider the fact that their opinion matters too. The excerpt made it clear like each opinion in a group of people makes it common decision and connects you to other people…if that makes any sense. One person didn’t just make up their mind and everyone followed. Everyone made their own choice in that group to believe what they do. Hugo reminds me of you home slice! =)

Master Liz said...

So what events exactly caused him to stray from his mother's beliefs? i would think that he would continue on with her views considering he grew up with it. But then again, that would completely go against his thoughts on individuality. ha. I agree with Hugo that every choice made is an individual's choice, no matter how significant it may be. Although, sometimes a person may make a choice to be like another. would that still fall under individualism? possibly. As for the painting he did, it really interests me. It's a rather unique work, and i definitely wouldn't have thought of it as being in a hole looking up until i read your post. I would be interested to see more of his art work. Actually i may look into that after i finish this.

Anonymous said...

Very interesting post, Bryan. I especially liked how you tied Victor Hugo's life into the life of Miranda July. (much better than mine. lol)
Anyway, I do have a few questions:
first of all, what made Hugo decide to lean to the left? Was it the rebellious nature present in all, causing him to want to go against his conservative household? or was it just because he had grown up and started to decide what he believed for himself?
another question: I'm still kinda hazy on the whole Romanticism thing (i know, sad, right?). I can't seem to get it. It seems to encompass such a broad range of ideas. So then, how do Romanticism and Republicanism relate to each other?

Julianne said...

We can see through his actions that Hugo did have the mind set of a Republican. The fact that he did not stick to the ideals of his mother and instead went out on his own for his philosophies shows that he was a revolutionary. His ideas were a product of his time, similar to how the treatment of women has changed over time. People are a product of the era they live in. What is considered chauvinism now was at the time in which it occurred was considered common place.
So back to the blog.
In your excerpt could the maypole be symbolizing the ideals of the past? All those who were involved departed to either the bonfire or the mystery play leaving the maypole behind in the cemetery. When I looked at the picture again I did see that the observer is in fact in the bottom of a pit. It seems as though the individual is in fact separate from the rest of the world, lost in an abyss of contemplation.
I need to read No One Belongs Here More Than You.

Padiller said...

I absolutely loved the way you presented Hugo. When we watched Les Moserables in class I could not picture the man behind the idea. In your blog you mentioned how he was influenced by Chateabriand. How did he influence Hugo? (Was it Chataubriand's beliefs or personal experiences? I would really like to learn about the man who inspired hugo and other Romantics.).

While reading your blog I also like the connection to the "Taches with fingerprints". I think I will take the time to read this novel and then use it to relate to Hugo's.

Ashley said...

This post was very interesting. I actually learned a lot and found out new things. I have never heard of Chateaubriand or Miranda July but you made very nice comparisons of the two.

On the note of his political beliefs as an adult...did anything mention why he would have went to the left? or was it just a personal way based on what he believed?

His painting was very weird, but enjoyable. Very different from anything i have saw before.

Really nice post brian.

Pooh Bear said...

Victor Hugo is an interesting character. I thought that it was funny how common it is for us( the kids), to stray away from our parents. Why did he feel so strongly towards rebuplicanism? Was it due to the time period? Usually when someone is born into a certain environment (conservative in his case) it is hard to fall away from it, but i guess those are only for some cases. But yea, i really like your opening quote. It gives us, the reader, an idea oh how he is and what he values. Something that really caught my eyes was his painting. It was very stange but i couldn't help myself staring at it. The emotion it gives offs is exactly as Hugo wanted to, when he painted it. I thought that the explaination for his painting was clever and so true.

mingthemerciless said...

love the quote! i guess everyone does. i guess b/c after those who does go through that phase realize it, they're like hey i was so stupid. but yea. he was different in that he broke away from his family. it seems as if conservative families are harder to break away from because they are so use to doing what the parents do or say. they usually dont have to think and just do what they were told